Scientia Advisors - Science, knowledge and skill for your competitive advantage

“Penny-wise, Pound-foolish” Tunnel Vision in Personalized Cancer Medicine

Posted by: Gauri R. Nair on October 25, 2011 | No Comments »
Related to: Healthcare Trends, In Vitro Diagnostics

LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Delicious

Next-generation sequencing technology has triggered a revolution in genomics and personalized medicine. Its ability to generate a snapshot of different cellular processes has led to an explosion of applications especially in molecular oncology. We at Scientia were pleased to welcome to our luminary insight series, Dr. Maureen Cronin, Senior Vice President at Foundation Medicine and a pioneer in the development of molecular diagnostic methods for oncology. According to Dr. Cronin, though it is widely accepted that cancer is a genomic disease, there is a tendency to restrict diagnosis to hotspots or markers specific to a cancer type. While recent research strengthens the notion that molecular subtypes are not restricted to a specific cancer, current genome profiling methods suffer from limited biopsy tissue, the inability to address biomarker complexity and an underappreciation of insertion-deletions and copy number variations. Successful personalized cancer treatment must integrate genome technology with advances in biology, management information systems and clinical oncology.

Tunnel vision in cancer testing might lead to a few pennies saved in the short term , but also to false negatives. Targeted therapy based on a wide genome profiling will result in cost-effective, long-term patient management. A wide genome profiling approach to targeted medicine may be more valuable and lower long-term healthcare costs. Instead of using the conventional disease anatomical approach, a high complexity multi-analyte test that sequences the entire cancer genome will enable physicians to identify molecular subtypes that are outside the scope of limited testing. Unfortunately, pan-cancer testing does not fit into a traditional treatment paradigm-legacy framework for regulatory approval and clinical trials do not accommodate new diagnostic technology and genomic understanding. Educating physicians and payers about the need for pan-cancer testing is necessary to overcome barriers to entry for this ecosystem. We believe that the standard of personalized cancer medicine must be to provide a patient with his/her specific molecular cancer landscape. This may enable targeted therapies to be used across tumor types, resulting in long-term savings of indirect healthcare costs, in contrast to currently approved MDx tests where incentives are not always aligned with patient benefits.

Related post on how Dr. Maureen Cronin inspired Patrick Terry, Principal at Scientia Advisors

Read more posts from Gauri R. Nair

Tags: , , ,


Leave a Comment

All fields are required.

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Subscribe via RSS »

Receive Posts via Email »



Browse Categories


About Scientia’s Blog

Scientia Advisors Blog offers strategic insights on the latest in the health care, life science and biotech industries. It is a company blog to which many Scientia team members contribute.


Archives

April 2013
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010


SCIENTIA ADVISORS, LLC  |  info@scientiaadv.com  |  A Precision for Medicine Company


55 Cambridge Parkway, Suite 300E, Cambridge MA 02142  |  Phone: 617-299-3000  |  Fax: 617-812-0315

© 2013 Scientia Advisors LLC